Kluge:

The problem is that the CLT gives a completely different answer:

Kan = 6/18 "Kan" = 17/31

So Kan per the CLT is NOT the Commonly credited Name.

Skip

Quoting Woola:

Quote:
Kluge:

The problem is that the CLT gives a completely different answer:

Kan = 6/18 "Kan" = 17/31

So Kan per the CLT is NOT the Commonly credited Name.

Skip

Sorry Skip, but if we reed the CLT results we can clearly see that the common name is Kan, because it appear in 5 title, while "kan" is only in 2 title...
I'm confused.

He's credited without any quotes in Seed of Chucky as per the CLT results.

Don't know what the other guys are on about, your maths seems ok to me Kluge as long as the other credits come back right.

PS. It might be helpful to know that Spinnen des Todes is the German title for the 2001 TV movie Earth vs. the Spider if anyone has it under that title instead.

It's down to the poorly entered data. Once you filter them down to what they should be entered as "Kan" only has two distinct titles - AvP: Requiem & Monkeybone, all others are only variants of those two titles. On the other hand Kan has 4 titles, again once you filter out those that SHOULD be linked together.

It calls for no assumptions at all & variations of credited names don't factor into the equation AT ALL. The ONLY thing that factors in to it here is that they haven't been entered correctly (typically original title and/or formatting per the rules). If they had been the numbers would be the correct amount.

What? We can't assume that Alien vs Predator 2 and AVP 2 or that Nutty Professor - The Klumps and Nutty Professor: The Klumps are the same films? 

Faggot:

What a strange name. We have proven that Credit lists are NOT necessarily the same across Versions, Region or Localities that a film may be released in . For example, one of the most famous these is two separate releases of Con Air which in one has Dave Chapelle credited and the other one has David Chapelle.

As has been stated numerous, times Faggot, since you are new to this party. This has been PROVEN. In fact over a year ago I began an experiment, based on what seemed a reasonable assumption, in fact the SAME assumption that this discussion is centered on.  That there would be ONE set of Credit for any given film, it seemed reasonable. I called on the Community to help with this experiment by verifying their own credits against the assumption, it took less than for that premise to beproven invalid, I repeat less than ONE WEEK. We don't know how often this happens, I suspect far more often than we might think, but that it happens at all invalidates any such assumed contributions.

Alos the Rukles do not tell us to make the kind of adjustments that Kluge is trying to make or that Forget is supporting, they simply say to use the CLT results, which he has not done. If adjustments need to be made in the future as other copies are properly verified, then that can easily be done, but no assumptions. When you assume something you make an Ass of U and Me.

Skip

Quoting Woola:

Quote:
...

Alos the Rukles do not tell us to make the kind of adjustments that Kluge is trying to make or that Forget is supporting, they simply say to use the CLT results, which he has not done. If adjustments need to be made in the future as other copies are properly verified, then that can easily be done, but no assumptions. When you assume something you make an Ass of U and Me.

Skip

Skip/DP/Jubal/Woola,

You are missing what Kluge is saying; The "17" Titles are just "2", 4 ways to write "Monkeybone" and 13 ways to write "Aliens VS Predator 2". This leads to the other entry which was 6 titles.

pdf