Doesn't change anything ace. It can be dealt with through the bonus feature film.

Oh good grief. Want to argue  sys trek iv being a comedy.  I think that's probably a personal call, ace. Is it not called ultimate edition, or something similar, to me that would put the extended cut first, but that's me.

"One Complete Set"
"4-Disc Collector's Set"

Something tells me this is a set.

That's good enough, ace.

Considering that it's not listing the Motion Comic as a bonus film, it should be a box set.

Quoting TheMadMartian:

Quote:
Quoting Alien Redrum:

Quote:
Considering that it's not listing the Motion Comic as a bonus film, it should be a box set.

I don't think that should be the determining factor either as there is no industry standard that I am aware of.

True, but you yourself said this:

Quote:
The determining factor, based on my understanding of the rules, is based on the answer to one simple question...is it being sold as a multi-film set or as a single release that includes bonus feature films?

There isn't a mention of these being bonus feature films. It doesn't say they are bonus films, so it shouldn't be assumed they are.

Quoting Alien Redrum:

Quote:
True, but you yourself said this:

Quote:
The determining factor, based on my understanding of the rules, is based on the answer to one simple question...is it being sold as a multi-film set or as a single release that includes bonus feature films?

There isn't a mention of these being bonus feature films. It doesn't say they are bonus films, so it shouldn't be assumed they are.

The rules define a Bonus Feature Film as "any feature film that is included as part of the bonus material for a single release."  My simple question is based on that definition which, if you will notice, doesn't say it has to be labeled as a bonus film.  It doesn't say that because the release that caused this rule to be created, Ben-Hur: Four-Disc Collector's Edition, doesn't have the 1925 version listed as a bonus film.  It simply states that The 1925 Silent Version is on Disc 3.  I am not asking you to agree, just offering my opinion.

That being said, now that I have had a chance to think about it, there is another question that has to be answered...is the Watchmen Motion Comic a feature film?  Based on the examples given in the rules, my answer would be 'no'. 

This is a live issue again on the actual profile. I submitted it as not a box set with the ultimate cut of the movie on the parent and the motion comic and theatrical version as children. I didn't think this was correct, but that's how this thread went. Now, someone has added it and the votes seem to be supporting my view. Has the consensus changed?