Quote:
The rule about using the data from the HD came out of discussions of conflicting data. The program design and common sense make it impossible to take it as a blanket statement. Otherwise, you end up with the diea that you shouldn't check DVD as a medium because you are supposed to get data from the HD disc. As others have pointed out, combos combine the fields for DVD and Blu-ray. This had to be intentionally programmed, so it doesn't make sense to call it an oversight with no further evidence. I think the only way to interpret the rule in question that's consisent with the original discussion and with the program design is that if there is a conflict between the SD and HD data, you should use the HD data.

Quote:
Discussions and disagreements should be able to be made without insulting accusations such as "deliberate obfuscations" or "damage that some users have done to both the rules and the online with absurdity."

Comments such as these are not productive and do not contribute anything positive to the discussion.

Quote:
The rules:

"Section Clarification / Adjustment to Rules
Title The title for a Box Set should be the title listed on the front cover, for example Alien Quadrilogy
Production Year Production Year for a Box Set should be the year of the earliest feature release in the set.
Running Time Use the combined running time of all the films in the Box Set; do not include running time of any extra features.
Rating If the Box Set has a rating, use it in the profile. If it does not, use NR as the rating. Exception: If any disc in the set is rated Adult, list the set as Adult
Disc IDs Do not include any Disc IDs on the main profile - these are listed on each of the individual profiles.
Easter Eggs Do not include any Easter Eggs on the main profile - Easter Eggs will be handled within the individual profiles.
Credits Do not use credits for the box set - Credits will be listed on the individual profiles. For additional information on handling of TV Series type releases see the TV series section.
Overview If the box set cover contains a listing of contents with brief descriptions of each, enter it directly into the Overview field.  If there is no overview on the cover, an overview from an included booklet may be substituted.  Otherwise, enter an itemized listing of the contents only, without descriptions.

In addition to the above, the following are not included on the box set profile: Subtitles, Audio & Disc Features. List them with the individual profiles.

Sets containing the same film on multiple media types (such as a Blu-ray/DVD combo pack) are to be entered as a normal profile for the main media type (Blu-ray in this example), with all included media types checked. A combo which includes HD media (HD-DVD, Blu-ray) as well as DVD should use the details from the HD media in the main profile. However, you may add an additional profile by Disc ID for the DVD content and add this profile to the Box Set contents for the Blu-ray profile."

I have carefully read this many times. The last paragraph is the one that seems to be the point that some feel makes this issue clear that the Video Format should be excluded.

If you read and apply the entire section, invelos has singled out exactly what parts we do NOT include in these cases:

- Disc Id
- Easter Eggs
- Credits
- Subtitles
- Audio
- Disc Features

Where in the rules do they tell us that Video Format should be excluded from the parent profile?

As far as I know, it doesn't.  Which is why I believe the issue is not as clear as some people.

I don't mind if other people do not agree, but I have the right to express my opinion and it is just as valid as anyone else.

Discussions and disagreements should be able to be made without insulting accusations such as "deliberate obfuscations" or "damage that some users have done to both the rules and the online with absurdity."

Comments such as these are not productive and do not contribute anything positive to the discussion.

Quote:
Quoting Scooter1836:

Quote:

Well how do you want me to reword that to vote yes then

You don't have to change a thing - the voters and screeners can look at the situation and make their own decisions.