Is the following example of Divider use correct:

DIVIDER: Dr. Jenning's Makeup Design
Crew: Name
Crew Name

It's for the Howard the Duck blu-ray. I removed them on the basis that the divider is a Job Title and NOT a divider.
I received NO votes based on the fact that the rules say that we should use Dividers for "crew teams".

Personally, I would say this comes down very firmly in the same camp as Songwriter/Song dividers.

I've resubmitted with a better explanation in my notes; but now feel that I may be overlooking something and want to make sure.

Quoting Pantheon:

Quote:
Is the following example of Divider use correct:

That depends.  Which direction is the wind blowing?

---------------

Dr. Jenning's Makeup Design belongs in the Custom Role field.  The Role is Makeup Artist.  No divider.

Quoting TheMadMartian:

Quote:
Quoting tweeter:

Quote:
Dr. Jenning's Makeup Design belongs in the Custom Role field.  The Role is Makeup Artist.  No divider.

This.

Agree 

.

Quoting Kathy:

Quote:
Quoting T!M:

Quote:
No divider. Not for make-up artists, not for songs, not for the writer of the novel the film is based on, and not for anything else like that.

The rules tell us "Dividers allow the segregation of cast and crew into logical groupings. Wherever possible, these groupings should mirror the film credits."

Make-up artists, musicians, writers etc. fall under Crew - why shouldn't they be listed?

Because crew are already segregated in logical groups such as writing and music by the program. In fact the rules tell us to "list individual credits only". A group credit is not an individual credit. The single exception allowed by the rules are for company names heading a group of crew members.

Quoting KinoNiki:

Quote:
The single exception allowed by the rules are for company names heading a group of crew members.

Read the rules again my friend. There's nothing in the rules that says it to be company names only. It only tells us that company names aren't allowed in the the crew except as a divider. And later on in the rules: "Dividers allow the segregation of cast and crew into logical groupings. Wherever possible, these groupings should mirror the film credits."

And quoting Ken Cole's response on some users claiming that only company names are allowed:

Quote:
This is saying that we don't list company names as credits, we list them as a group divider.  It does not say that we only list the company name. 

Dividers help give context to the credits in the group.  That is not best served by excluding this extended information.  Include it.

In the example given by Pantheon it's a job title that belongs into the Custom Role field. e.g. Song names just aren't.

So dividers must mirror the credits as much as possible (e.g. headings) and it has to give context. It can't be a job title because that's already pre-programmed into the program and can be changed by the custom role field. That's how I would summarize the divider rules concerning the crew table, based on the rules and Ken's statements.

I disagree with your interpretation of the rules, sorry.